I'd like to share a story regarding internet "expertise" in the context of how it might possibly apply to coin beginners vs. coin experts.
As the story goes, this collector has another hobby, and that hobby is quite a bit more technical than coin collecting (save perhaps counterfeit detection).
Eager to learn more about his new interest, he chanced across a site filled to the brim with experts who could help him. The "seed" of this problem started
here when hapless collector could not tell who was an expert—and who was
not.
Having learned a little knowledge and with some related diagnostic gear, he posts a few well-done analyses (he assumes) with questions. Despite his reasonable statements, a few "experts" remind him of a past mistake and seemingly dismiss those conclusions.
It must have been sheer folly, because the beginner then defended his conclusions based on clear, documented evidence collected by him. He also questioned why a past mistake should possibly apply here, and unwittingly questioned the conclusion of the "expert".
What followed was like a kick to a
raging bee hive, followed by "stings" of innuendo, verbal abuse, and browbeating--public and private. Alas, this poor guy didn't see it coming! This sheep was properly shorn.
Btw, that hypothetical person was me. And perhaps I deserved some of it.
Now I'm
not looking for sympathy here; I wrote this to make a point, because I know this place is a healthy community of rational people—beginners and experts alike. It bears saying.
I offer this in defense and empathy of beginners everywhere.
If you're an expert, newbies won't immediately know that and fail to give you the credit for your time and expertise. Consequently, respect of your position and expertise
takes time outside those who know you. I'm sure as an expert, you know the importance of good leadership towards earning respect and consequently gaining influence. Without respect, there is little influence, is there?
Sometimes newbie collectors are very excited about their new hobby
It's important not to mistake their energy and resultant errors as something malicious towards you.
That's about it—did I miss anything? If I'm the butt all those people think I am, tell me please.]]>
View the original article here